In my previous blog, I provided a brief overview of the four technology approaches in the market for preventing digital ad fraud and mitigating bot traffic. For instance, many anti-fraud platforms in the market today use a single pixel embedded in an ad in order to identify and track unsolicited non-human traffic. The heritage of the single pixel approach comes from ad serving technology and it’s a powerful way to track and measure digital ad fraud. Vendors in this space include White Ops, Integral Ad Science, Forensiq and DoubleVerify.
The heritage of the reverse proxy approach was derived from IT security and is a powerful way to stop non-human traffic before it interacts with a website’s origin servers. That is to say, a reverse proxy approach seeks to answer the question “is this a real human attempting to access my website?” and get the answer without any false positives and without interrupting the user experience in any way. A reverse proxy enables the incorporation of a multitude techniques, such as turing tests (e.g., CAPTCHAs), while maintaining control and offering a variety of methods to manage bot traffic once detected. Below is an analysis of the single pixel approach versus using Distil Networks as the exemplar reverse proxy vendor.
Overview of pixel with ad approach
Overview of Distil Networks reverse proxy approach
Distil sits inline with web traffic on a publisher site or advertiser’s landing page and inspects each http request in real time, determines if it’s a bot or not, then passes the request to origin. Distil analyzes 40+ criterion from each client request then builds a fingerprint unique to the browser making the connection. Fingerprints are “sticky” to the bot even if it attempts to reconnect from random IP addresses or hide behind an anonymous proxy. Distil interrogates the browser to ensure the browser is indeed who it claims to be. Challenges to the browser are inserted and the responses reviewed dynamically to prevent pre-emptive spoofing.
Distil uses behavioral analytics and machine learning to minimize false positives and optimize protection for each domain. Being inline, Distil can periodically intercept suspicious traffic that does not fit with the site’s unique traffic patterns and challenge it with a hardened turing tests, and then feed the response data back into its machine learning algorithms. Distil gathers attack information across customers and distributes it back out to all Distil-protected sites.
Key differences between single pixel with ad approach and Distil Networks’ reverse proxy
The heritage of the single pixel with adtech translates into strong end-user fraud reporting and auditing capabilities. However, in analyzing Distil Networks’ technology, three key advantages rose to the fore.
Proactive. A pixel is a reactive signal while Distil is a proactive mechanism. A pixel will signal a suspicious request and provides advanced reporting which can be used to audit an advertising program or adjust ad rates after the fact. Distil’s reverse proxy takes action on the fraudsters before a page loads. This approach has other advantages in that it protects against random spikes in bot traffic, skewed analytics, and other online threats such as web scraping, spam, transaction fraud, and brute force attacks.
Domain Specific. The single pixel approach relies on data across a vast network of sites yet there is little or no domain-specific behavioral modeling or heuristics based on requested URLs, click path, or speed of navigation. Distil leverages domain-specific human behavior and machine learning to identify dangerous anomalies. This is not possible with a single pixel firing from creative.
The bottom line
Digital publishers may benefit by using a layered approach to stopping digital ad fraud in which they combine the pixel in ad approach with a reverse proxy service like Distil Networks.
About the Author
Charlie Minesinger is the Director of Sales at Distil Networks focused on strategic accounts and channels. Charlie has over a decade of experience selling into enterprises and brand accounts, including Sprint, Disney, Nortel, Amazon, Cisco, AIG, Mattel. Charlie brings with him experience in start-ups and selling into new markets.Follow on Twitter More Content by Charlie Minesinger